Echo Show 8 (2024) in Charcoal vs Echo Show 5 (2024) in Charcoal

In comparing the ‘Echo Show 8 (2023) in Charcoal’ and ‘Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal’, it is essential to weigh the features and functionalities of these two smart home devices. While both devices bear the hallmark qualities of Amazon’s Echo line, they cater to slightly different needs and preferences. By examining their specifications and capabilities, users can make an informed decision based on their distinct requirements. Let’s delve into a comparative analysis to better understand which device may be better suited for your specific needs.

Home Entertainment

Echo Show 8 (2023) in Charcoal
Echo Show 8 (2023) in Charcoal
as of April 7, 2024 3:18 am



The all-new Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen, 2023 release) presents an immersive entertainment experience with spatial audio, an 8″ HD touchscreen, and a 13 MP camera, all framed in a sleek Charcoal design. Acting as a smart home hub, it simplifies control over various devices, features vibrant visuals, and ensures privacy with multiple protective layers, making it a stylish, functional addition to your space.

Enhanced Entertainment

Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal
Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal
as of April 7, 2024 3:18 am



The Echo Show 5 (3rd Gen, 2023 release) offers enhanced sound quality with 2x the bass and clearer vocals. Featuring smart home connectivity, a built-in camera for video calls and home monitoring, and eco-friendly design elements like recycled materials.

Echo Show 8 (2023) in Charcoal

7.9” x 5.5” x 4.2”

Display Size
8″ HD touchscreen

Audio Quality
Room-filling spatial audio

13 MP camera

Smart Home Integration
Built-in smart home hub, Zigbee, Matter, and Thread compatibility

Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal

5.8” x 3.6” x 3.2”

Display Size
5.5″ display

Audio Quality
2x the bass and clearer sound

2 MP camera

Smart Home Integration
Smart device control, video doorbell compatibility

Echo Show 8 (2023) in Charcoal


  • Entertainment Excellence: 8″ HD touchscreen and spatial audio for a superior viewing experience
  • Smart Home Integration: Built-in smart home hub for seamless control of compatible devices
  • Environmental Consciousness: Made from 29% recycled materials, showcasing sustainability efforts

Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal


  • Clear sound quality
  • Good for setting reminders and timers
  • Sleek and modern design

Echo Show 8 (2023) in Charcoal


  • No Netflix app available
  • Poor quality camera

Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal


Comparison chart


Echo Show 8 (2023) in Charcoal


Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal

Display Size

8-inch HD screen


5.5-inch compact screen


Spatial Audio technology for immersive sound


2x the bass output with clearer sound

Smart Home Hub

Integrated Smart Home hub for controlling compatible devices


Works as a Smart Home hub for smart devices

Virtual Assistant

Alexa built-in with voice control for hands-free usage


Alexa voice control with seamless integration

Camera Quality

High-resolution camera for video calls and security monitoring


Enhanced camera quality suitable for video calls and home security


Sleek design with modern finish


Compact and stylish design


Wi-Fi, Bluetooth compatible for ease of connection with other devices


Enhanced Wi-Fi connectivity

Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) USPs:


      • Spatial Audio: Enjoy immersive sound quality.

      • High-resolution Camera: Ideal for video calls and home monitoring.

    Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) Pros:


        • Larger HD display for enhanced viewing experience.

        • Spatial Audio technology for immersive sound.

        • Integrated Smart Home hub simplifies home automation.

      Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) Cons:


          • Larger display size may not suit compact spaces.

          • Higher price point compared to Echo Show 5.

          • May have more features than some users require.

        Echo Show 5 (3rd Gen) USPs:


            • Enhanced Audio: 2x the bass output and clearer sound for an improved audio experience.

            • Compact Design: Ideal for smaller spaces where a larger screen might be overwhelming.

            • Affordability: Provides great value for its price point.

          Echo Show 5 (3rd Gen) Pros:


              • Enhanced audio quality with improved bass output.

              • Perfect for small spaces with its compact design.

              • Value for money proposition.

            Echo Show 5 (3rd Gen) Cons:


                • Smaller screen size might not be suitable for everyone.

              Conclusive Assessment:

              Based on the comparison, the Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) emerges as the winner due to its larger display, spatial audio technology, and advanced smart home hub integration, making it ideal for users looking for premium features and immersive experiences. However, for users prioritizing affordability and compact design, the Echo Show 5 (3rd Gen) offers great value without compromising on essential features.

              Final Summary:


              For those seeking a premium smart display with advanced audio and smart home capabilities, the Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) is the top choice. On the other hand, for users looking for a budget-friendly option that fits well in smaller spaces, the Echo Show 5 (3rd Gen) is a great pick without sacrificing essential functionality. Choose according to your priorities and requirements for the best experience.

              Alternative Echo Show Options

              Comparing Echo Show Products: A Comprehensive Guide

              When comparing products in the Echo Show category, it is essential to consider various factors to make an informed decision. The following guidelines will help you evaluate the key features and make a well-informed comparison between Echo Show products.

              Factors to Consider


                  • Screen Size: Evaluate the size of the display screen to determine which product suits your needs better.

                  • Resolution: Consider the resolution of the screen for a clearer image and better viewing experience.

                  • Sound Quality: Compare the audio output capabilities of each product to ensure quality sound.

                  • Smart Home Compatibility: Check for compatibility with other smart home devices you may have.

                  • Design & Color Options: Consider the design aesthetics and color options available to match your preferences.

                Key Features


                    • Echo Show 8 (2023) Charcoal:


                          • Larger screen size for better visibility.

                          • Enhanced resolution for crisper images.

                          • Superior sound quality with built-in speakers.

                          • Improved smart home integration capabilities.

                          • Sleek design available in charcoal color.

                      • Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal:


                            • Compact screen size suitable for smaller spaces.

                            • Good resolution for everyday use.

                            • Decent sound quality for its size.

                            • Basic smart home compatibility.

                            • Available in charcoal color option.



                          • Echo Show 8 (2023) Charcoal:


                                • Ideal for larger rooms or spaces.

                                • Great for watching videos or movies.

                                • Enhanced sound quality for music or calls.

                                • More advanced smart home integration options.

                                • Sleek design that complements modern decor.

                            • Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal:


                                  • Perfect for bedside tables or cozy nooks.

                                  • Adequate for casual video calls or music playback.

                                  • Basic smart home control for essential tasks.

                                  • Fits well in compact spaces.

                                  • Affordable option for those on a budget.

                            By considering these factors, key features, and benefits, you can effectively compare Echo Show products and choose the one that best suits your needs and preferences.

                            Common Questions about Echo Show

                            What are the key differences between the Echo Show 8 (2024) and Echo Show 5 (2024) in Charcoal?


                            The key differences between the All-new Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen, 2023 release) and the Echo Show 5 (3rd Gen, 2023 release) in Charcoal are mainly related to size and capabilities. The Echo Show 8 features a larger 8-inch display compared to the 5.5-inch display on the Echo Show 5, offering a more immersive visual experience. Additionally, the Echo Show 8 likely incorporates more powerful speakers and enhanced sound quality due to its larger size, providing a more robust audio experience. In contrast, the Echo Show 5 may prioritize compactness and space-saving design. These differences in size and audio capabilities can impact the overall user experience and preferred use case for each device.

                            How does the audio performance compare between the Echo Show 8 (2024) and Echo Show 5 (2024) in Charcoal?


                            The audio performance of the All-new Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen, 2023 release) is enhanced with Spatial Audio, providing a more immersive sound experience compared to the Echo Show 5 (3rd Gen, 2023 release). The Echo Show 5 offers 2x the bass and clearer sound, but it does not feature Spatial Audio technology like the Echo Show 8, which can contribute to a richer, more dynamic audio output.

                            Which device offers a better display quality, Echo Show 8 (2024) or Echo Show 5 (2024)?


                            When comparing the display quality between the All-new Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen, 2023 release) and Echo Show 5 (3rd Gen, 2023 release), the Echo Show 8 will likely offer better display quality. This is because the Echo Show 8 generally features a larger screen size compared to the Echo Show 5, which typically results in better visual experience and image clarity. Additionally, the Echo Show 8 may have a higher resolution display, thus providing a more detailed and vivid viewing experience. Consider these factors when making your decision on display quality between the two devices.

                            Show all Most Helpful Highest Rating Lowest Rating Add your review
                            1. Could you elaborate more on the sound quality comparison between the Echo Show 8 (2023) and the Echo Show 5 (2023)?

                            2. My favorite from the comparison list would be the Echo Show 8 (2023) in Charcoal. The bigger screen is more appealing for my needs.

                            3. Thank you for sharing your preference! The larger screen size on the Echo Show 8 does make it more versatile for various tasks.

                            4. I recommend the Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal for smaller spaces like kitchens or bedrooms. It’s compact and fits well on a bedside table.

                            5. In my experience, the Echo Show 8 (2023) in Charcoal is excellent for video calls with its clear display and camera quality.

                            6. It would be interesting to see a comparison with the upcoming Echo Show 10 model to see how it stacks up against the Echo Show 8 and Echo Show 5.

                              • That’s a valid point. Comparing the latest models can provide valuable insights into the improvements and new features introduced by Amazon. We’ll consider that for future content.

                            7. I personally prefer the Echo Show 8 (2023) in Charcoal over the Echo Show 5 (2023) Charcoal because of the larger screen size. It’s great for watching videos and following recipes.

                            8. I’ve used both the Echo Show 8 (2023) and the Echo Show 5 (2023) in my home office setup, and they’ve been incredibly helpful for managing tasks and playing music.

                            9. I suggest considering the Echo Show 10 for a more advanced smart display option with motion tracking capabilities.

                              Leave a reply

                              Compare items
                              • Total (0)
                              Shopping cart